The second game of the match between [the Empire and Aetna] took place on the afternoon of the 23d, at St. Louis Base Ball Park, in the presence of a goodly number of spectators. The grounds were in admirable condition and the weather all that the most ardent lover of the game could desire. The playing, though not characterised by any very brilliant display, was a close contest and showed an improvement on the play of the former game some two weeks since, especially at the bat.-Missouri Republican, May 25, 1869
The Empire's Wirth is to be credited with a fine running fly and some very excellent play at 1st base, which was more in his old style than anything he has given lately. Fitzgibbon, pitcher, did well, and is evidently improving, his balls being delivered with more accuracy and regularity. Murray, short-stop, did some handsome fielding to 1st base, and captured his share of the "flies." Barron, catcher, "filled the bill" admirably, though he is not fully at home in that position, and we cannot but think that it is a mistake to take him from his own position of short stop, in which he has no equal hereabouts. Of the Aetnas we must say they played a fine fielding game, displaying much activity, and in throwing of balls more accuracy and skill than their opponents. Kenney, catcher, did great execution both behind and at the bat. Savignac at 1st is a promising player, as also O'Brien, 3d base, who should use more care in batting and running the bases. Tighe, at 2d, is in the right place, and did safe business at the bat, but was "out of luck." Messrs. Whalen, Carroll and Wheeler filled their positions with credit and did some fine batting.
The result of the game we give below, and, considering all things, it is creditable to the Empire Club, if it is not of the same huge proportions as the previous one. Mr. H. Smith of the Union Club, filled the position of Umpire with much credit to himself and general satisfaction to the players.
James Barron, who is described here as the best shortstop in St. Louis, was one of the cornerstones of the great pioneer-era Empire Club. He was a mainstay at shortstop, playing with the first nine from at least 1867 to 1875, and a member of seven championship clubs. Barron was also the Empires' field captain in 1869.