About 2,000 persons attended the base ball game between the Keystones, of Philadelphia and the St. Louis Unions at Union Park yesterday afternoon. The visitors put in Weaver to pitch in response to a generally expressed desire to see him in the points. He was, however, in no condition, being suffering from a lame arm, and was unable to do much more than toss the ball to the batsman. On one occasion he stopped a hit with his left hand, and there was a chance for a double play, but he was unable to throw, and in an effort to pitch the ball to Peak sent it low out to center. He held the points until the eighth inning, when he retired to left, Hoover went to third and McCormick undertook to do the twirling. The features of the game was a home-run by Gleason, double-plays by Rowe and Quinn of the home team, and Hoover and McGuinness, of the visitors. The home nine scored 20 hits with a total of 35 bases. A total of 6 singles represented the visitors work at the bat.-St. Louis Globe-Democrat, May 31, 1884
I just don't think that it was a good idea to throw a dead-armed pitcher against the 1884 Maroons.
And What Did Dunlap Do against a pitcher with a lame arm? About what you would expect. He had three hits, including two doubles, and scored four runs. Doesn't really seem fair, does it?